Clan Tartans

The Origin of Clan Tartans
by James Scarlett MBE

There has long been controversy, often heated and frequently acrimonious, as to when, sometimes exactly when, "clan" tartans began to be used. Some have held that the 'Scots' emerged from the primeval mists wearing their identifying tartans, others that Sir Walter Scott started it, and there have even been a few who would lay it at the door of Queen Victoria's Prince Consort, Albert.

There is little logic in any of these opinions. An organised system cannot exist without organised communities and uniform tartans require both technology to make them and mass-production to encourage them; they are therefore unlikely to have come into being until weaving had become a specialised trade in its own right. It is doubtful if even the wizardry of Sir Walter could have conjured up the complete Clan Tartan System and all that goes with it, more or less overnight and, while Queen Victoria did a great deal towards founding the romantic reputation of the Highlands - which still endures - it has to be said that the beginning of the Clan Tartan Idea came before her time.

It has to be remembered that, in the present context, tartan is Highland and that the Lowlands did not adopt it in the 'family' sense, to any large extent, until the mid-eighteenth century, when the Lowland tartan industry had begun to grow up as a result of the 1747 Act which sought to abolish tartan altogether. My recent research into military tartans suggests strongly that the blue, black and green tartans owe their existence to military fashion or even War Department ruling: this is not to say that all such tartans are military ones but that the army started the idea. The other class of dark tartans, those known as 'hunting', almost certainly derive jointly from a rather obscure statement by George Buchanan (see the right hand column) and the strident colours of the early synthetic dyes. A third class, many-hued, comprises the Sobieski confections, which are either inventions or minor modifications of established tartans of their time.

Laying these three classes aside as being late, standing out from what remain are three variations on a theme in red, green and dark blue, each with its own geographical affinity. Naming them by the clans who use the simplest versions, they are, in the West the Macdonald type which has a broad green stripe with a narrower blue one on each side, in the central Highlands, running from Strathglass in the north well into Perthshire, the Mackintosh type in which green stripe is divided by a wide central red stripe, and north of the Great Glen the Ross type in which the green and blue elements are in separate blocks.
However, there are some exceptions: Stuarts of Appin and MacDonells of Keppoch are associated with tartans of the Mackintosh type; the now-forgotten MacPherson of Cluny's tartan, listed by Wilsons'before the end of the 18th century, Loch Eil Tartan, another early listing by Wilsons', which I think was probably worn by Locheil's men in The '45, and one associated with the Fraser contingent at Culloden are also of the pageType, giving a distinctly Jacobite undertone to the pattern.

The Jacobite Army in The '45 was organised in Clan regiments and in such a long and mobile campaign some re-equipment must have been necessary so, however the men may have been dressed at the outset, it is probable that a considerable degree of uniformity must have ensued which resulted in clan regiments eventually wearing uniform tartans that became Clan Tartans by a natural process. Whatever inferences enthusiastic protagonists may draw from the totally inadequate evidence, there is no clear reference to the use of tartan in the 'clan' context before The' 45 and the Clan Tartan Idea made rapid progress very soon after. There seems to be a strong probability that the Clan tartans are a direct legacy of the last Jacobite Rising.

When large numbers of prisoners were taken, groups of them wearing the same tartan and the individual groups wearing recognisably similar tartans it would have been hard for the responsible Government authorities to avoid seeing in tartan a badge of underground armies. A ban on tartan in disaffected areas would be a natural outcome and can be seen as a precaution against a future outbreak rather than as some kind of punishment or a deliberate attempt to destroy the people.
J.S. 3rd May 2002

More ammunition!

A reasoned explanation was stated by Sir Thomas Innes of Learney, former the Lord Lyon King of Arms, who stated: " No doubt it was not until about the eighteenth century that the clan tartans became concious or acknowledged badges of identification. But that is not to say that they had not actually been badges of identification for a period, nay , it implies that they must necessarily have been so; for we do not recognize institutions while they are growing, but only realize them after they are, or have become, an accomplished fact. We may be sure that neither clan nor district tartans were originally invented as such. No one in the middle ages 'patented the clan tartan idea1; it arose naturally, and developed gradually, and was no doubt only conciously realised a generation before its proscription. The identity conception revived with renewed energy when that proscription was withdrawn."

The noted Highland scholar, Stewart of Garth, whose father was alive in 1745, and who had friends who participated in the Rising of'45, believed that old tartans, which for centuries had no special significance, came to have a district significance; that from this clan tartans naturally developed; and that clan tartans naturally developed; and that clan tartans existed prior to 1746.

Some of the tartans which existed prior to 1746, include; the Jacobite Tartan, the earlier mentioned Cameron of Lochiel, Dress MacRae, Lennox, the 'Royal Stuart1 (said to be an old MacRae tartan). The Hunting MacRae in present use is taken from a piece from a Kilt worn at Sherriffmuir in 1715. Huntly and Gordon tartans also date to before 1745. "Tartans was worn continuously from 1746 to 1782 by military formations, and although against the law, was worn blatently in the Highlands in 1773 (as Doctor Johnson and James Boswell recorded on their tour of the Hebrides). Dr. A.J. Lawrie , writing in Scottish Field.

Having said all this, it has to be accepted that most modern tartans date from the early nineteenth century but that fact cannot be allowed to overshadow the case for for many clan tartans existing long before the Sobieski brothers were out of juvenile pantaloons.